Single Family Home for Sale in Edgartown, #40142

Single Family Homes - Edgartown Downtown | 77 Cooke Street Edgartown MA
  • Rooms/BD
  • Bath(s)
  • SqF
    3,607 ft²
  • Price

Here is the in-town getaway compound you've dreamed of: As your seasonal vacation spot. Or as your year-round "secondary primary" home. Perhaps as your rental income magnet, too. Upgraded by successive owners, the property still honors the grace of the site's original 18th Century homestead, built for prominent Edgartown minister Joseph Thaxter. In the spirit of historic Edgartown, the current owners of this meticulously maintained property have upgraded the landscaping to garden-tour levels and re-opened the streetfront vistas to the appreciation of neighbors and passersby. The main house, built in 1970 and remodeled in 2004 by architect Pat Ahearn, features a lofty, open-concept great room with gourmet kitchen and wood-burning fireplace. The 2018 dining room addition offers egress to a sunny little patio for morning coffee. All four bedrooms -- two up, two down -- feature en suite baths and romantic gas fireplaces. One downstairs suite directly accesses the rear patio via French doors. Perfect for that right-out-of-bed dip in your 11x27 heated pool and spa. The two upstairs bedrooms each have private decks for basking in the sunshine. (The owner dubbed one suite "the McCartney Suite." Ask me why.) The Juliet balcony over the great room is a perfect spot for an office nook or for the children to spy on grownup conversations below. In the walkout lower level: Fully appointed studio quarters for the nanny, the caretaker or the collegian’s must-have hideaway. The 2018 improvements include a detached carriage house, with a one-car garage, storage spaces and an extra laundry room on the lower level. Above, a game room (or whatever you dream this bonus space to be) features a custom stone fireplace, wet bar and half bathroom. At ground level, a brick outdoor fireplace faces poolside, for cozy gatherings in the chilly shoulder seasons. You might never wish to leave home, but in case you do: Dinner in town is near to your doorstep, as is the bike path to South Beach. Included in the sale are the handsome furnishings -- darn near every convenience you could wish for, down to the lobster pot. Just move in and savor. NOTE: The quoted square footage (3607sf) combines the living areas of the main house, including finished basement area (2,791sf) and carriage house (816sf).

Floor 1: Great room with wood-burning fireplace, gourmet kitchen, dining room, two bedrooms with gas fireplaces and en suite baths, laundry.

Floor 2: Two bedrooms with gas fireplaces, en suite baths and private decks

Basement: Fully appointed studio quarters with independent entrance, patio and wood-burning fireplace. Mini-split heat/AC. Utility room.

Other Buildings: Carriage house, built in 2018, adding 818sf to the property's overall living space. Lower level: heated one-car garage; storage room with spare oversized washer/dryer; tool room. Upper level: game room with wet bar, half bathroom, mini-split heat/AC, upper deck overlooking the pool. Along the poolside exterior: brick fireplace, half bathroom, outdoor shower, propane grill nook with exhaust hood.

Second Dwelling:


Outdoor amenities
Hot Tub
Swimming Pool

©2023 LINK, All Rights Reserved. Not responsible for misinformation or typographical errors. Prices are subject to change without notice. Listed by: Donnelly + Co


  • Listing ID: 40142
  • Year Built: 1970
  • Flooring: wood, carpet
  • Yard: lawn and lavish garden beds at streetfronts; patio with pool/spa at rear
  • Foundation: poured concrete, slab
  • Water: Town
  • Heating: Gas\FHA